Friday, February 21, 2014

Fullmetal Shinobi Review!

Uzumaki Naruto with an Automail Arm!

 

For my first fanfiction review, I have decided to go old school. Sort of. Anyway, I wanted to review a story that was actually complete, and the first fanfic that came to mind was Fullmetal Shinobi by Kenchi618. As the man who got me motivated to begin writing my own fanfiction, I felt it was only appropriate.

What is there to say about Fullmetal Shinobi? Well, it was the first fanfic Kenchi618 ever wrote, as such it's not nearly as good as his later works, but still tends to be a cut above the rest. It was well-written, like with all his works Kenchi makes few grammatical mistakes. It was also an interesting enough story; as the fanfic that started Kenchi's fanfiction writing it tends to follow more cliche's than is normal for work from him. I feel this is acceptable as it was not only his first fanfic ever written, but it was written well enough that the cliche's didn't bother me much.

The story itself is about Uzumaki Naruto--of course, who else would it be about?--who loses an arm when a mob comes to "kill the demon!" Cliche, I know, but it gets better. He is discovered and saved by the fortunate arrival of Jushiro who, upon realizing that there's a boy MISSING HIS ARM, takes Naruto to the hospital. To make a long story short Naruto is given an Auto-mail arm...yes, it's the same arm that Edward Elric has, or close enough. Jushiro also decides to stay in Konoha and becomes a shinobi in order to take care of his new "brother"...and he teaches Naruto alchemy.

Can you feel the cliche yet?

Despite how generic the story starts, it's actually a pretty good read. Most of the fanfic tends to follow a more canon plot, with only a few small changes here and there...like Naruto having a metal arm and learning alchemy from Jushiro the OC, along with a few other differences. The story doesn't really start to change until after the Chunin Exams, which is when we go into more original territory.

On a side note, I believe it was around this time that Kenchi started writing his "The Sealed Kunai" fanfic, which may explain how the story managed to make such significant progress from "mostly generic canon plot" to "almost completely original story content."

In either case, the story deviates completely from canon after the Chunin Exams and brings a healthy dose of originality to the table. Combine with Kenchi's sarcastic writing tone and you've got an entertaining read. I would rate this story with a 9/10 due mainly to the lack of originality at the beginning. If you haven't read this one already, I suggest you do.

Fullmetal Shinobi

11 comments:

  1. You can never go wrong with FMA: Brotherhood. It is the best anime ever after all. I actually read some of that story about a month ago, but I discontinued reading it because it felt a bit generic and static. I guess that is understandable as it was Kenchi's first fanfic.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I would honestly suggest going back and reading it again. If you can plow through the first half until the Chunin Exams, the story will become much more original after that. It's not a bad story, though it's not something I would read twice.

      Delete
    2. Yeah, I didn't get to the Chunin Exams. I actually stopped at the end of the Wave Arc. Is it just me or does Jushiro look suspiciously like an Ishvalen?

      Delete
    3. I'm not sure. It's been so long since I read Fullmetal Shinobi that I can't actually remember what Jushiro looked like.

      Delete
    4. They describe him as having silvery-white hair, tan skin, and red eyes. That is the appearance of Ishvalens from FMA: Brotherhood.

      Delete
    5. That is true...I wonder if that's a coincidence.

      Delete
    6. With Kenchi, do you really he would leave something to coincidence?

      Delete
    7. Well...it was his first fanfic.

      Delete
  2. Another important thing to remember is that Kenchi is said to train martial arts himself, maybe nothing eastern, like kung-fu, but rather MMA-style fighting, but it still gives him that fighting mindset and imagination of what works, is possible etc. he's one of 3 authors that i have in authors alerts: Leonineus(which sadly stopped writing Naruto and then at all), Kenchi and you :P ice work on those reviews, keep up, maybe i'll find something that i didn't know earlier.

    ReplyDelete